“Drill, baby …” Oops, Never Mind

Not long ago, I wrote – pretty favorably – about Pres Obama’s decision to open up some offshore areas to more drilling and petroleum development. I said then that decades of technology improvements have substantially reduced the risks of accidents and spills.

Well, that statement was certainly factually true when I made it, and it’s no less true today. But the BP disaster off Louisiana shows that the risk isn’t ZERO. We don’t know yet just where the system failed – equipment malfunction, poor design, or human error – but there was a failure point, and it is within our ability to identify it, along with the culprits.

Oil producers and drillers have lots of incentive to avoid these disasters. It will cost BP many times more in clean-up costs and bad publicity than they could ever have saved by cutting safety and environmental corners. But even if a company has the best of intentions – and it’s pretty clear now that planning for potential spills by BP, Halliburton, et al was dreadfully negligent – familiarity always breeds complacency, and it’s easy to become lax when you’re policing your own behavior.

Better oversight and regulation – by an independent organization that doesn’t have a direct stake in getting oil out of the ground – must be a major part of the response to this mess. Taking $$$ out of the hide of unfortunate or negligent offenders is satisfying, but bancrupting BP isn’t going to clean up the mess in the Gulf, bring back the dead fish, birds and turtles, or replace the lost tourism and fishing revenues.

Energy development is vital to our individual economic health and to our country’s basic security. But debacles like the BP mess underscore the urgency of developing alternative sources, along with more effective and reliable regulation of oil and coal resources.

And the fact that our near term energy mix will have to include a fair amount of oil that’s not from the Middle East as a bridge to a non-fossil fuel future underscores the urgent need for an independent regulatory body with the resources and teeth to make sure industry doesn’t cut corners when it comes to safety and the environment.


Tags: , , , ,

3 Responses to ““Drill, baby …” Oops, Never Mind”

  1. Tony Harris Says:


    Good timely comments. I agree with your vision of how to go about the business better management of our existing fossil fuels base while integrating a mix of other energy sources. It continues to make sense to me to also keep coal as a key part of the energy mix.

    • Bob Brothers Says:

      harris700’s comment about the importance of coal in our near- to medium-term energy mix is right on – even granting the dirty and dangerous nature of coal mining and burning. Thanks, Tony

      I’ve written a few times about coal – here’s a good example.
      Two considerations are paramount – incentivize industry to use coal in the cleanest and most efficient ways possible, and structure investment, tax, and regualtory strategies to encourage ealry and large scale commercialization of renewable energy technologies.

  2. Holt Says:

    By “independent”, I hope that you aren’t refering to congress. It would be a wonderful world if regulation were done by a totally apolitical entity…….I swear I haven’t been smoking anything.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: